Booker's vs. Noah's Mill: A Taste-off

While talking to Drew from Kentucky Bourbon Distillers on the phone yesterday, he mentioned the fact that his Noah's Mill expression really isn't that much more expensive than other high-proof Bourbons of similar quality direct from the distillery.  Jim Beam's Booker's Bourbon, for example.  Kyle and I saw that as an opportunity to compare the two side by side.  It had been a while since either of us had cracked these bottles, so we went into the tasting bar to see what we could decipher.  Is all the talk about overpriced NDP Bourbon really valid, or would Noah's Mill outshine the Booker's for the same price point?

-David Driscoll